We use cookies to improve your experience on our website. Accept | Find out more


Hive Minded

As beekeeping goes mainstream, eco-friendly urbanites are swarming-setting up home hives, producing honey and creating a greener planet.

Author Layla Schlack Photography Keliy Anderson - Staley

Image – Keliy Anderson – Staley

URBAN BEEKEEPING HAS BEEN GETTING A LOT OF BUZZ (and inspiring a lot of puns) in recent years. It began with scary reports of Colony Collapse Disorder (CCD), a mysterious ailment that has led to declining bee populations. Then there was the explosive growth of the local food movement, which has led people not only to favor homegrown honey, among other products, but has engendered a greater understanding of the importance of bees in local ecosystems. More recently, New York City legalized the cultivation of hives within city limits, and Michelle Obama had beehives installed in the White House garden.

Indeed, it seems bees are poised to replace teacup dogs as the nation’s must-have pet. But walking into Joel Eckel’s backyard in Philadelphia’s Germantown neighborhood feels more like a step back in time than an encounter with the latest fad. Eckel, who founded the Philadelphia Beekeepers Guild in the fall of 2009, keeps his six hives in a massive yard shared by three stately old homes, two from the 1840s and one from the pre-Revolutionary period. The hives abut a huge garden brimming with herbs, fruits and vegetables, just a few yards away from the chicken coop, where an impressive rooster strolls among his hens. Pointing to a pile of wood in a far corner, Eckel explains that he’s hoping to gather enough to heat his house by woodstove all winter. “Sometimes I like to just sit out here with a cup of coffee and watch my bees,” he says.

He’s not the only one. The guild has grown from 40 members to more than 100 in under a year, and it’s not just a Philadelphia phenomenon. “I’ve never seen anything like it,” says Michael S. Thompson, farm manager for the Chicago Honey Co-Op, a cooperative bee farm of about 60 hives. “I’ve been teaching beekeeping since I was in my twenties—I’m in my sixties now—and there’s never been such a surge of interest. I’m having to turn people away from my classes, and I have folks cold-calling me to volunteer on the farm.” Meanwhile, the New York City Beekeepers Association, founded in 2008, was already 220 members strong when the city lifted its ban on hives this past March, bringing in a wave of new recruits. The group’s president, Andrew Cote, has taught beekeeping to dozens of beginners (newbees?) since the hobby became legal. Last year San Francisco—always at the forefront of foodie trends—saw the opening of the first U.S. boutique devoted to urban beekeeping. And Londoners can employ the services of Honey Bees at Home, which will build a hive, fill it and come around to check on the bees.

You might even say it’s the bees knees.

And why not have your own hive? Start-up costs are low, the effort required is relatively minimal, and the end result is decidedly sweet (if you don’t mind the occasional sting). Plus, the trend is providing a powerful answer to CCD. As Eckel explains, one theory for the disorder that’s gained currency among scientists is that since most commercial beekeeping has long been done in rural areas, where colonies are brought in to fertilize crops, the bees were generally consuming just one type of pollen—and therefore became malnourished. Left to their own devices, bees will travel two miles to forage for nectar, which in an urban area can include some pretty diverse territory, ensuring a varied diet.

In Philadelphia, beekeeping is a part of the city’s historic legacy. Lorenzo L. Langstroth, the father of modern beekeeping, was born here 200 years ago. Langstroth’s chief contribution was the movable-frame hive—still the default for beekeepers today—which is what allows apiarists to remove combs without angering the colony. The guild is raising funds to erect a plaque at Langstroth’s birth site, hopefully in time for next month’s Honey Festival.

In an age when specialty honeys such as Greek, New Zealand and Tupelo are available at high-end grocery stores, and connoisseurs know the benefits of each, local honey inspires hometown pride. “I’m kind of a honey addict, and I really wanted South Philly honey,” says Adam Nicely, who works in medical publishing and keeps a hive on his neighbor’s roof. “It’s nice just knowing that something like this can exist in this neighborhood.”

Back in Eckel’s backyard, as the sun peeks out after a short rain, the bees begin to swarm out of the hive and into the garden, totally indifferent to a four-year-old named Jolie, whose father, Philadelphia beekeeper Adam Schreiber, has stopped by to check out Eckel’s swarms. “When it rains, all the bees go inside their house,” Jolie explains, flouncing her princess dress as she walks among the hives. “But now it’s not raining, so they can come out.” Schreiber says that Jolie, a junior apiarist, loves to help out with the hives, especially using the smoker to make the bees more docile, and she’s totally unafraid. “I’ve never gotten stung,” she brags. Kids and bees might strike some as a bad combination, but many youngsters are fascinated by the creatures. “I figured it would be best just to let him get stung, so that he’d learn how to behave around them,” Eckel says of his own three-year-old, Isaac. “The poor kid, he got stung right in the face. I felt so bad. But it hasn’t deterred him at all.” Eckel also keeps a hive at the William Penn Charter School, where he teaches kindergarten.

Fortunately, most honey bees, especially the Italian and Carniolan varieties most common in the U.S., are known for their gentle nature. However, recent years have seen an influx of Russian bees. They’re more resistant to mites—another suspected cause of colony collapse—but the Russians are also thought to be more sting-happy than other species. Still, David Harrod, the webmaster for the guild’s site, phillybeekeepers.org, says bees are really only aggressive when they have reason to be. “If they’re busy and productive, then they’re happy,” he explains. “If the weather is bad, or there’s no nectar, or their queen is missing, then they can be very aggressive. Besides environmental conditions, some colonies can develop aggressive tendencies based on genetics, too. When they do you usually replace the queen.”

Harrod started his first hive four years ago, which makes him a relative veteran among the many young members of the Philly guild. He and a friend now have about 20 hives, which he expects will generate several hundred pounds of honey this year. In the past, he’s given it away to friends and family. But with a bumper harvest this year, he might actually sell some. Still, for Harrod, the business opportunity is secondary. “I’ve just developed a real love for bees,” he says with a smile, admitting, “It’s surprising to find yourself emotionally attached to insects.”

Senior editor LAYLA SCHLACK can also be very aggressive when she’s hungry.




Probably one of Langstroth’s design. Paint as you please.

They can be purchased in “nucs” (nuclei) that include a queen.

To protect your face

Calms the bees so they won’t sting when you’re extracting honey

Bees will build honeycomb on special etched sheets.

9 Responses to “Hive Minded”

  1. Dave Harrod Says:
    August 1st, 2010 at 12:38 pm

    Please visit our site, especially the Langstroth Historical Marker page to find out more about the inventor of the modern beehive. Also check out he Philadelphia Honeyfest which will be held this fall to celebrate Langstroth, beekeeping, and local honey in Philadelphia and beyond!

  2. Terri Lorah Says:
    August 3rd, 2010 at 10:42 pm

    Very interesting article. I found this fascinating.

  3. Lori Covington Says:
    August 4th, 2010 at 1:40 pm

    With Colony Collapse Disorder affecting one-third of commercial hives, thousands of homeowners are taking up the challenge to raise healthy bees the organic way. Organic beekeeping relies on using essential oils and basic beekeeping know-how to prevent mite infestations and to keep bees as healthy as possible. Beeing (oops–being) a bee afficionado, I love blogging about bees and beekeeping, gardening for my bees and helping other people take their first steps into establishing home apiaries. When the home hive becomes as ubiquitous as the washing machine, I’ll figure my work is done–not a moment sooner!

  4. T Sandoval Says:
    August 13th, 2010 at 9:26 pm

    While it was a good, brief introductory article, it also gave some not entirely accurate information.

    For example, in the “generate some buzz” section about starting a hive, it most certainly does not have to be a Langstroth style hive, there are other types of hives in use called Top Bar’ hives that are being used more and more.

    Also, in the article, the author claims that it is ‘inexpensive’ to start beekeeping. It can be ‘relatively’ inexpensive IF, one builds their own hives and instead of purchasing bees, they capture swarms instead. Then yes. Otherwise, those nucleus hives referred to in the article average about $125.00 each and packages of about 3 pounds of bees going at about $85 each.

    If one purchases the equipment they will spend about $300.00 minimum for the full hive plus a hat and veil (if they feel they need one). As the hives grow, especially Langstroth style hives, each additional box can cost between $8.00 and $15.00 each depending on if they are pre-assembled or not.

    It is not uncommon at all for a beginning beekeeper to accumulate all of the items they need to start beekeeping and buying everything retail to spend between $500.00 and $1000.00 Langstroth style hives also happen to be the most expensive hives as they require more parts.

    I love the fact that you are encouraging beekeeping but I would love to see a more thoroughly researched and presented article that gives a more accurate representation of what actually goes into beekeeping.

    Beekeeping is not a “set it and forget it” type of hobby. it requires a lot of ones time and attention to properly manage and sustain healthy bee colonies.

  5. Deborah Barry Says:
    August 20th, 2010 at 2:52 pm

    I just read this article on board an United flight. I wanted to add that Colony Collapse Disorder is very possibly caused by a rather new pesticide group that has affected the bees all over the world. There is a wonderful documentary on this called Nicotine Bees. It was released just this year 2010. I would highly recommend checking it out!

  6. Roger Weld Says:
    August 21st, 2010 at 2:37 pm

    Good read and I’m sure a lot of people will have their interests peaked. They may want to check out this book on natural beekeeping techniques.

  7. J. Martinez Says:
    August 26th, 2010 at 7:52 pm

    Think about starting your own hive. Besides being good for the environment, you’ll meet many fine support people and beekeeping is fascinating. You can do it!

  8. Karen Eddleman Says:
    September 1st, 2010 at 11:16 am

    This article (in the magazine) included several other stunning B&W photos, which unfortunately are not included in this online version. Kudos to Kelly Anderson, the photographer.

    I’ve been keeping three hives in town for five years now! It is a great hobby with SWEET benefits!

  9. Gerry Says:
    December 1st, 2013 at 1:22 pm

    Urban beekeeping is certainly to be encouraged, especially with times being so hard for bees. I read somewhere that the, surprisingly, urban bees are doing better than their country cousins. i.e. they are not falling prey to CCD, or at least not as much.

    Anybody else have any information on this?

Leave your comments